Tim Duncan or Shaquille O'Neal: who is more accomplished?

Tim Duncan 4 Titles,2 MVPs,3 Finals MVPs
Shaquille O'Neal 4 titles,1 MVP,3 Finals MVPs

Wow good question... I'm having a tough time deciding but Timmy did it all with one team and is loyal and keeps his mouth shut. Just for that, I pick him.

Last edited by Philly KDub on Tue Jun 16, 2009 7:26 am; edited 1 time in total

Man, that's a very difficult question to answer. Both guys are great players. Both accomplished a lot in their careers. I'd have to give an edge to TD due to his 2 regular season MVP awards and I believe he is much better defensively than Shaq. It is a crime that TD never won a DPOY award.

Rookie Posts : 23 Points : 5486 Join date : 2009-06-13

Shag.He can still dominate and i know he will his 5 ring and retire as one of the greatest players ever.He wants a 5 rings because that will add to this averges 26,1ppg,11,8 rpg,2,4 bpg

It's a shame that Duncan hasn't won the Defensive Player Of The Year award yet

Darko

Shaq is the better individual player, but Tim was the better team player. They are really really close.

I'd have to go for Tim Duncan. Shaquille O'Neal is better as an individual, but Tim Duncan has just done better improving his team.

This is another tough one, I was just reading an article about Tim Duncan and how developed and aware he is in the game. They are both great players that are very accomplished, but I think it goes to Tim Duncan. He's a great all round player, whereas Shaq still struggles in some aspects. Tim Duncan is a true team leader, Shaq always seems to be competing with someone whether it be Kobe, Wade or Nash.

-A Fellow Melo Supporter

Cavs Browns Indians wrote:: Wow good question... I'm having a tough time deciding but Timmy did it all with one team and is loyal and keeps his mouth shut. Just for that, I pick him.

Philly KDub wrote:: Man, that's a very difficult question to answer. Both guys are great players. Both accomplished a lot in their careers. I'd have to give an edge to TD due to his 2 regular season MVP awards and I believe he is much better defensively than Shaq. It is a crime that TD never won a DPOY award.

TK12 wrote:: I'd have to go for Tim Duncan. Shaquille O'Neal is better as an individual, but Tim Duncan has just done better improving his team.

Ryan - The Aussie Fan wrote:: This is another tough one, I was just reading an article about Tim Duncan and how developed and aware he is in the game. They are both great players that are very accomplished, but I think it goes to Tim Duncan. He's a great all round player, whereas Shaq still struggles in some aspects. Tim Duncan is a true team leader, Shaq always seems to be competing with someone whether it be Kobe, Wade or Nash.

-A Fellow Melo Supporter

Yeah. Duncan did it with either Robinson, or Parker/Ginobli. Way harder than Bryant/Fisher/Malone/Divac and Wade/Posey/Walker/Payton/Williams.